I thought WATERS OF MARS was a very good episode. If I was a kid I think I would have found it pretty scary stuff!
*
DON'T READ THIS IF YOU'VE NOT SEEN WATERS OF MARS!! SPOILERS!!
*
*
*
OK Gripes first - Adelaide I found to be quite insufferable; her indignation at the Doc's "little people" line is more than a little hypocritical considering the b**chfaced manner in which she treated her staff throughout the first half of the ep. - although of course the events she had witnessed could have changed her...
Adelaide's easy acceptance of everything the Doctor tells her about her death seems to gel not one whit with her tough, no compromising attitude. Having said that she is more than a little bipolar. One minute she's got a gun on the Doctor, the next she's handing him his space suit and saying bon voyage! huh? Security? Adelaide shooting herself is simply based on the Doctor telling her a bit of babble. Hardly logical, despite what had occurred on Mars and achieved without Adelaide getting actual empirical verification on anything (that we see at any rate). One minute she's defying the Doctor's prognosis on her fate with a steely determination to survive and the next she's trying to blow the base up at the point of victory and then finally topping herself!
"Bowie Base" - naff pop culture reference - it's 2050 something ffs!
Probably the only other thing I disliked was the Doctor's over theatrics when seeing the ood and hamming "Is this death?" like some kind of Lawrence Olivier parody. (In this scene the ood is virtually operating as The Watcher - compare the 4th Doctor's stoicism in the face of it.) The 10th Doctor's vainglorious personal obsession with himself is becoming so reflexive of fandom's obsession with David Tennant that I really wonder what RTD will leave us with... his "little people" line regardless of whether or not it was said in a moment of power bloodrush is one of the most repellant things I've ever heard the Doctor say and sums up the intermittent distaste I have had for the 10th Doctor over the last two years.
These points aside, I found the rest of the episode to be compelling viewing. It took the best tropes of the Troughton era and reworked them marvellously. We have the classic multinational base under siege where one by one they are picked off and we have an innocuous thing being presented as a deadly killer. DW has always been terrific at making the known unknown and in this instance water being the culprit is a great idea. I think around the interweb the Gadget robot has been receiving a bit of stick but I thought it was a good mood lifter for what was otherwise a pretty grim story and I was extremely impressed with the acting, sets and effects throughout. Sure, the story was more than a little similar to TIP/SATAN PIT but as that was one of the best episodes in the series so far then it can't harm to re-jigg it a bit. The real plus for this episode was the Doctor's moral dilemma. Although I have my doubts about him actually giving away so much to the doomed crew (it raises all sorts of questions regarding free-will versus "fitting" your behaviour to what you've been told) but it did draw into sharp focus what time travel is potentially all about. Did like those shots of the Doctor's skull-like face in the spacesuit when he's leaving the base - did anyone else think he looked liked Death itself?! Very clever.
End of Time preview didn't do much for me but I'm wondering if the Doctor's tampering with a "fixed" historical moment is going to throw the whole universe out of whack hence this is why The Master is alive again (oh no not more John Simms doing Jack Nicholson doing The Joker) and probably the Time Lords will be back too because of it. This starts to get me wondering about the 11th Doctor. I wonder if the Time Lords catch up with the Doctor and give him the War Games treatment - considering that the new TARDIS pictures look like the original I wonder if the 10th Doctor is de-regenerated - sort of rebooted back to the beginning by the Time Lords, but in a universe that has been altered by his choices in WOM...
Edited by Sniperscope, 21 November 2009 - 12:45 AM.