I don't like it when the same character is recast from one film to the next.
Generally, I agree. But I would have hated it if Rachel Dawes was just thrown out the window as a character. What's special about this Batman franchise is the continuity between films, and it's good to see that the established relationship from BATMAN BEGINS will carry through into the next film. I'd much rather have the Dawes character stay than another "girl of the month" (which was one of the primary things wrong with the previous Bat franchise).
Eckhart's talented, but I just can't see him and Ledger holding their own with the likes of Bale, Caine, Freeman, Oldman, and Gylenhaal.
Really? I can.
Easily. Ledger and Eckhart are certainly in Bale and Gyllenhaal's league (if not in Caine, Freeman, and Oldman's).
I think that casting Sean Penn (who I think would have been brilliant in the role) would have been the right move, even if he's a bit old for the part, with all the makeup I'm not sure that it would have mattered all that much.
Sure it would have. The Joker needs to be Batman's age. There can't be the old guy/young guy dynamic. And personally, I have yet to see anything from Sean Penn that convinces me he could really make the Joker a charismatic villain. He's a good enough actor, but has no charisma to speak of.
I'm also not sold on the first picture of The Joker. It looks less like the Joker and more like Heath Ledger wearing lipstick.
Did you expect it to
not look like Heath Ledger? Honestly, you seem so downbeat about every film these days, tdalton (aside from HALLOWEEN, unbelievably). It's been a while since I heard you say anything positive about a recent film.