I think Bana would be a nice, safe choice -- not one that will turn me off Bond, and not likely one that would attract tons of new fans either.
He is quite tall, I believe 6'3", and I have seen him on talk shows and he's very charming. His background as a comedian probably helped a lot in that respect. He has the same kind of affability as Jackman. He may also be vulnerable to the same "too much of a homebody, regular Joe personality" criticism that Jackman is.
He's quite a talented actor. You can't judge his "charm" by Hulk. There, he was playing a very quiet and repressed character, and IMO, he did it well. It was the general opinion that, in a heroic role, he stole "Troy" away from Brad Pitt. I haven't seen his movie "Chopper", in which he plays a violent charmer, but I've heard nothing but great things about it -- it was the breakthrough that got all these studios interested in getting him to headline huge films.
However, he doesn't 100% look the role. His head is rather gawky, and he looks better a bit scruffy, which is inappropriate for Bond. And it does bother me that he's not British.
Still, he can pull it off because he is an excellent actor, certainly very physically fit, and a charmer. I do not much trust AICN as a source though.
I also question whether he would make such a move. His career is actually going exceedingly well. "Hulk" and "Troy" were both disappointments relative to expectations, but still, he has starred in two massive blockbusters. And he's the star of one of Steven Spielberg's next projects. Also, he is a homebody and has kept his working schedule pretty sparse.
Edited by Spoon, 28 July 2004 - 10:43 PM.