Dear GoldenEye,
I didn't like you then and I still don't like you now.
You are easily the most overrated film in the series.
Brosnan is fantastic. Shame the rest of you is so dowdy.
Your younger brother Tomorrow Never Dies is everything you failed to be.
Best wishes,
A curmudgeon who likes whizzing in people's popcorn.
I kind of agree with you. I can praise GoldenEye for saving the franchise commercially, but I have some criticisms artistically of it.
First off, I never liked the 006 teamwork thing. Bond works alone. Who's this guy he's supposedly friends with and saying "buy me a pint?" Bond drinks hard liquor, not beer (I know, Craig's Bond now drinks beer.) But Bond is not a buddy action movie (correction--unless she's hot and badass!)
I never liked how it handled Bond resigning from Licence to Kill. Did old M give him his job back? Or new M? Would have preferred Judi's M taking over, and Tanner telling her "there's only one man for the mission."
And the line "Your predecessor kept cognac in the cabinet?" So Brosnan is the same as Moore's Bond? This one line ruins any attempts to explain continuity with the Judi Dench M of Craig's Bond. GE can't be after CR because Bond knows about her predecessor! GE/TND/TWINE/DAD has to be viewed as its own series, and yet TWINE's references to OHMSS and DAD's references to every Bond movie!
Plus, the PTS set "nine years" earlier than 1995, while an inside joke to Pierce's original casting as Bond, wipes out TLD/LTK from the canon. "I don't want you going off on some revenge mission."--M. "Never"--Bond. Umm...the last Bond movie?
Bond escaping helicopter with ejection seat was a ripoff from Die Hard 2 where John McClane does the same thing.
Music score was disappointing.
GoldenEye does have its merits (as I noted earlier in this post), but at the end of the day, I do prefer Tomorrow Never Dies. Still, without GoldenEye, there may never have been another Bond film after LTK.