The emergence of a male M at the end of "Skyfall" bodes the return of a long-running debate in Bond fandom. Ever since Robert Brown appeared as M in 1983s "Octopussy" the debate has raged. Was Brown the same Sir Miles that Bernard Lee portrayed so capably for 17 years? Or was he returning as Admiral Hargreaves, a character Brown had played in "The Spy Who Loved Me"?
Despite the fact that Brown was never named either way there are possible clues. Michael G. Wilson when asked in 1981 about recasting Bond's superior was quoted as considering returning a previous figure in the Bond universe, but did not elaborate. Then in the 1990s a Danjaq commissioned and EON approved CD-ROM was released that named Brown's M as Hargreaves. Then several years ago an eagle-eyed Bond fan noted that Brown's M sported a lower rank in his "The Living Daylights" pre-credits sequence than he had 10 years previous in "The Spy Who Loved Me".
This seemed fairly conclusive at the time and many fans hailed it as definitive proof that Brown could not be Hargreaves.
However in 2009 I accepted a position to work for The Washington Post as a contractor for the U.S. Navy. A Google search on my name and Navy will reveal some if the articles I wrote for navy.mil and the DoD.
In one quiet moment with a Chief Petty Officer, I recounted this debate. He scoffed at the supposed uniform "proof" as "irrelevant" and cited a number of examples of naval officers who are demoted and forced to take desk jobs after some serious infractions. He claimed to know one demoted officer who had to work for naval intelligence.
Indeed in the year and three months I worked on the contract with the Navy I met two officers who had been demoted in rank. One of those two now holds a position of great responsibility at the Pentagon.
So, with "The Living Daylights" uniform issue now discredited the debate continues and is likely never to be resolved.
It also threatens to intensify with the closing minutes of "Skyfall". If Ralph Fiennes appears in the next 007 movie will fans claim that he is Sir Miles or Gareth Mallory? Time may tell.