Jump to content


This is a read only archive of the old forums
The new CBn forums are located at https://quarterdeck.commanderbond.net/

 
Photo

'You Only Live Twice': Movie vs. Novel


5 replies to this topic

Poll: 'You Only Live Twice': Movie vs. Novel

'You Only Live Twice': Movie vs. Novel

You cannot see the results of the poll until you have voted. Please login and cast your vote to see the results of this poll.
Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 Qwerty

Qwerty

    Commander RNVR

  • Commanding Officers
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 85605 posts
  • Location:New York / Pennsylvania

Posted 15 December 2005 - 02:52 PM



Which of the two do you prefer and why? The original 1964 novel by Ian Fleming; often cited to be one of the best in the series? Or is it the 1967 Sean Connery film?

I'll be adding my own reply soon.

#2 Loomis

Loomis

    Commander CMG

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 21862 posts

Posted 15 December 2005 - 06:12 PM

The novel. I love the film version (in fact, I consider it one of the very best Bond flicks ever), but the novel is simply the greatest (the only?) work of art associated with James Bond. I've raved about it at tremendous length on several occasions here on CBn, so I won't go into it all again here. But, yes, the novel, definitely the novel.

#3 K1Bond007

K1Bond007

    Commander RNVR

  • Commanding Officers
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 4932 posts
  • Location:Illinois

Posted 15 December 2005 - 06:28 PM

Personally, the movie. I'm not a huge fan of the movie (when speaking in comparison of the others), but I'm even less of a fan of the novel. I don't see what is so great about it. In my opinion, the novel is slow and not at all what I would expect Bond to do after the events of OHMSS. Ultimately Bond gets revenge, but the revenge is just.. too coincidental for my liking. I think Gardner got this right in Scorpius when Bond got his revenge there - and everything about that situation wasn't even legit.

Then theres the ending, which is just... weird.

#4 Genrewriter

Genrewriter

    Cammander CMG

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 4360 posts
  • Location:South Pasadena, CA

Posted 15 December 2005 - 06:50 PM

I like both about equally. The book is very good and while the film does have some pacing issues it's still a fun piece of entertainment.

#5 BondReader 007

BondReader 007

    Sub-Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • Pip
  • 155 posts
  • Location:Phoenix, Arizona USA

Posted 16 December 2005 - 11:36 AM

While the movie was good, I have the side with the written word. The novel was great. In my opinion, not Flemmings' best but still one heck of a book. Congrats to anyone reading it for the first time.

#6 Lazenby880

Lazenby880

    Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • PipPip
  • 937 posts
  • Location:London

Posted 03 January 2006 - 12:41 AM

The novel, by far.

The movie YOU ONLY LIVE TWICE sort of falls apart after an exhilirating opening, to the point where it is one of the few Bond films during which I look at the DVD player to see when it is going to end.

YOU ONLY LIVE TWICE the novel is another story entirely. Certainly the best of Fleming's novels, it rises above its pulp origins to become a true work of literary art. Lyrical prose, superb and well-drawn supporting characters and a weird and wonderful plot deliver a novel that registers a deeper impact and has far greater resonance than any of Fleming's previous novels (or THE MAN WITH THE GOLDEN GUN). Above all it is a fascinating study into James Bond's character, whose slow but steady decay from CASINO ROYALE reaches its nadir in YOU ONLY LIVE TWICE. With a melancholy dreamlike atmosphere that pervades the pages, many of the ideas within are indeed bizarre, but these bizarre ideas are presented by Fleming in such a way that they never stretch beyond belief and ensure that the novel is one of the most memorable.

A truly great and captivating work.