Jump to content


This is a read only archive of the old forums
The new CBn forums are located at https://quarterdeck.commanderbond.net/

 
Photo

The 'Royale' Couple


74 replies to this topic

#31 SecretAgent007

SecretAgent007

    Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • PipPip
  • 660 posts
  • Location:Central Pennsylvania

Posted 26 October 2005 - 05:32 PM

It kind of sounds like this movie may get bogged down with a lot of extra baggage. I hope not though. I can't see where they are coming from with all of this. The general public do not buy tickets to see this type of Bond film. They want escapism and fun, like "villians in volcanoes" as Zen was saying. If you want something darker and gritty, go see a Bourne film. :)
Don't get me wrong, if it gels together I think it will be good, but the hardcore fans won't make CR a blockbuster.

Edited by SecretAgent007, 26 October 2005 - 05:34 PM.


#32 Loomis

Loomis

    Commander CMG

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 21862 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 05:34 PM

It all sounds so very serious, doesn't it? They are making a serious James Bond movie, you see, and that of course means "better." I mean, who wants to see another turkey like Dr. No or Goldfinger or Thunderball or You Only Live Twice or Live And Let Die or The Spy Who Loved Me or Octopussy or GoldenEye or...

I've never understood the "no more villains in volcanoes" edict.

But, hey, if they're trying to make another From Russia With Love more power to them. At least they have their feet planted firmly in Fleming, so hopefully Casino Royale really will be another From Russia With Love and not another Licence To Kill or The World Is Not Enough.

View Post


Well said. But they seem to have attempted a "serious" James Bond movie every time out since 1986. :)

The encouraging thing, though, is that it does at least look as though they might be doing "serious" properly this time round. :)

#33 Bondesque

Bondesque

    Sub-Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • Pip
  • 428 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 05:35 PM

I would just love to see Bond seduce a bond GIRL or any girl for no other reason then that he wants to get laid.

We haven't had that since Connery!

#34 Harmsway

Harmsway

    Commander

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 13293 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 05:45 PM

It all sounds so very serious, doesn't it? They are making a serious James Bond movie, you see, and that of course means "better." I mean, who wants to see another turkey like Dr. No or Goldfinger or Thunderball or You Only Live Twice or Live And Let Die or The Spy Who Loved Me or Octopussy or GoldenEye or...

View Post

To be fair, I think of the films you mention, GoldenEye was pretty darn serious. The humor in that film just kind of fades away under this very grim tone, aided by the grayish cinematography.

And let's not forget that Casino Royale as a novel is fairly serious. It is right there with FRWL and OHMSS in its tone, not really an outlandish novel. And that's how it should be approached.

By all means I want to see another Bond movie full of the bizarre and awe-inspiring sets and action, but in Casino Royale, by no means. I want a very serious movie. We'll see where the rest of the Craig era goes, but it'll be nice to see a man who's closer to Fleming in my mind than the past three Bonds have been (and people shout, "What about Dalton?" - well to be fair, I never really pictured Dalton as Fleming's Bond; Dalton was just never rugged enough for the role in my mind, or as charming, or charismatic, etc.).

#35 Loomis

Loomis

    Commander CMG

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 21862 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 05:50 PM

It all sounds so very serious, doesn't it? They are making a serious James Bond movie, you see, and that of course means "better." I mean, who wants to see another turkey like Dr. No or Goldfinger or Thunderball or You Only Live Twice or Live And Let Die or The Spy Who Loved Me or Octopussy or GoldenEye or...

View Post

To be fair, I think of the films you mention, GoldenEye was pretty darn serious. The humor in that film just kind of fades away under this very grim tone, aided by the grayish cinematography.

View Post


Agreed. But I'd say that CASINO ROYALE needs to be even more serious than GOLDENEYE. There's a lot of goofy humour in GOLDENEYE that I can't imagine working in CR (and, unsurprisingly, I don't think much of it really works in GOLDENEYE either).

Like I say, as long as they do "serious" well....

#36 Harmsway

Harmsway

    Commander

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 13293 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 06:05 PM

It all sounds so very serious, doesn't it? They are making a serious James Bond movie, you see, and that of course means "better." I mean, who wants to see another turkey like Dr. No or Goldfinger or Thunderball or You Only Live Twice or Live And Let Die or The Spy Who Loved Me or Octopussy or GoldenEye or...

View Post

To be fair, I think of the films you mention, GoldenEye was pretty darn serious. The humor in that film just kind of fades away under this very grim tone, aided by the grayish cinematography.

View Post


Agreed. But I'd say that CASINO ROYALE needs to be even more serious than GOLDENEYE. There's a lot of goofy humour in GOLDENEYE that I can't imagine working in CR (and, unsurprisingly, I don't think much of it really works in GOLDENEYE either).

Like I say, as long as they do "serious" well....

View Post

Agreed.

#37 triviachamp

triviachamp

    Lt. Commander

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPip
  • 1400 posts
  • Location:Toronto

Posted 26 October 2005 - 06:09 PM

Why would you guys want a goofy Bond movie? That sounds like Batman fans calling for the return of Joel Schumacher!

#38 Kara Milovy

Kara Milovy

    Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • PipPip
  • 842 posts
  • Location:New York area

Posted 26 October 2005 - 06:15 PM

I would just love to see Bond seduce a bond GIRL or any girl for no other reason then that he wants to get laid.

We haven't had that since Connery!

View Post


You're kidding, right?

I give you:

Lazenby: Nancy (the German girl at the clinic)
Moore:

#39 David Schofield

David Schofield

    Commander

  • Discharged
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 3026 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 06:27 PM

I think you're reading of Fleming Bond is highly romantic! Sure, Bond gets involved with women, but purely as entertainments. Hence, his boredom of the routine of affairs that is mentioned in CR. And any feelings he has - other than Tracy - are no so great that he commits in any sense long-term. Women are a short-term diversion, a compensation. Isn't there one phrase - in Pearson's biography and an extract from unpublished Fleming - where Bond muses that he finds domesticity abhorent and becoming indistinguishable from run of the mill people disgusting?

View Post

I think a romantic reading is legitimate. Timothy Dalton, in interviews in 1986, talked about reading Fleming for the role and how romantic Bond was.

You say no long-term except Tracy, but that's just incorrect. We know he lived with Tiffany for about a year, we know he proposed marriage to Vesper. We know he imagines if a long-term is possible with Tanya and realizes it can never be, and feels some sorrow over that. He's a cold bastard, but he's not disengaged. It's not that he doesn't care; it's that he cares deeply and pushes the feelings down.

View Post



And what, for heaven's sake, makes James Bond, secret agent, fall in love with Electra? Feel sorry for her, yes: in love - never. This is the man of the world, the tough man who is only a silhouette.

View Post


That is a very odd quote to use to support your argument, David! It comes from the end of Fleming's MOONRAKER, when Bond is putting on a brave face after Gala has told him she's going to marry someone else. Out of duty to himself and to her, and not to make a scene, he plays the part expected of him: the tough man of the world. That's not at all who he feels like at that moment, though. He's already thinking about taking her to France and so on, and perhaps of life later.

Bond continually falls for women. Sure, Solitaire and others are described as 'the prize' - but it's essentially the same thign each time over. Bond meets the most extraordinary woman ever, falls in love with her, worries how he can reconcile that with his life as a secret agent, and then the thing doesn't work out. Same thing each time, and no acknowledgment of the previous women. I don't think Vesper is ever mentionmed again in the novels - which is kind of odd, isn't it? I think this is something the films have actually kept. Bond and the girl melt into each other's arms at the end, and it's not just sex - it's 'Oh James' and champagne. By the next film, it's a given that that girl is not around anymore. And yet Bond seemed to deeply care for her, and saved her life, and so on... We feel that he can have any woman he wants, and has lots of one-night stands, but the woman in this particular mission is special. Perhaps not love, but special. And it restarts after every film.

All of which presents a real difficulty in adapting this novel to screen, I think. They may have cried wolf a couple of times too many. It's not a new idea for Bond to fall in love - even if it wasn't convincing in TWINE, it was there.

View Post



And what, for heaven's sake, makes James Bond, secret agent, fall in love with Electra? Feel sorry for her, yes: in love - never. This is the man of the world, the tough man who is only a silhouette.

View Post


That is a very odd quote to use to support your argument, David! It comes from the end of Fleming's MOONRAKER, when Bond is putting on a brave face after Gala has told him she's going to marry someone else. Out of duty to himself and to her, and not to make a scene, he plays the part expected of him: the tough man of the world. That's not at all who he feels like at that moment, though. He's already thinking about taking her to France and so on, and perhaps of life later.

Bond continually falls for women. Sure, Solitaire and others are described as 'the prize' - but it's essentially the same thign each time over. Bond meets the most extraordinary woman ever, falls in love with her, worries how he can reconcile that with his life as a secret agent, and then the thing doesn't work out. Same thing each time, and no acknowledgment of the previous women. I don't think Vesper is ever mentionmed again in the novels - which is kind of odd, isn't it? I think this is something the films have actually kept. Bond and the girl melt into each other's arms at the end, and it's not just sex - it's 'Oh James' and champagne. By the next film, it's a given that that girl is not around anymore. And yet Bond seemed to deeply care for her, and saved her life, and so on... We feel that he can have any woman he wants, and has lots of one-night stands, but the woman in this particular mission is special. Perhaps not love, but special. And it restarts after every film.

All of which presents a real difficulty in adapting this novel to screen, I think. They may have cried wolf a couple of times too many. It's not a new idea for Bond to fall in love - even if it wasn't convincing in TWINE, it was there.

View Post



Very right Spy.
And from a woman's point of view.. we never really think of Bond as a "cold-hearted bastard". those are the villains, not Bond. Bond is a "cold-hearted bastard" IN SURFACE, but actually a "chivalrous, strong, passionate" man deep down. This combination, and his sexiness, his wit, good looks, charm and dangerous life are what make us women fall for Bond.
Every girl he has, is at the centre of his attention in that very moment. A woman knows when she's dealing with a dangerous man, and things are not meant to last because of his life. But falls for Bond nevertheless, because of how he is and be cause he REALLY cares for her in that moment.
Doesn't matter if they don't get married and she won't be there afterwards. We (women) know that. But we want him anyway because of how he is. And because, in that very moment, as Spy very acutely said, it's "oh james" and champagne. And not "get off your clothes, goodbye."

View Post


Sorry, Kara, Spy, Alessandra, Bond is a bastard. He uses women. Its not that he doesn't know how to settle down: its that he can't, doesn't want to. He doesn't want domesticity. Offering to marry Vesper and going through with it is a diferent matter. Sure, Spy, the quote is from Moonraker - Bond is feeling sorry for himself he didn't get into Gala's knickers, surely. Must be brave, can't show emotion 'cos I've missed out. Sure, he spends a year with Tiffany. A year. Well done him! Then he moves on. He gets over each woman fairly quickly.

Don't romanticise this man. Bond is a sensualist. Women are both his pleasure and his release. Or shall we really say he is Amis' Byronic hero? I think the error is to sympathise with Bond and make him too nice. Kara, to quote Dalton, "he is a bad lad", and not just slightly.

Edited by David Schofield, 26 October 2005 - 06:29 PM.


#40 Harmsway

Harmsway

    Commander

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 13293 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 06:32 PM

I agree with Schofield's interpretation of the Fleming Bond. He loved two women: Vesper and Tracy. All the rest, while he was certainly attracted to and had a level of caring for them, never qualified under love.

#41 Loomis

Loomis

    Commander CMG

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 21862 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 06:43 PM

Why would you guys want a goofy Bond movie? That sounds like Batman fans calling for the return of Joel Schumacher!

View Post


Goofy is fine by me, as long as it's done well. In other words, I'd accept CASINO ROYALE as a zany pantomime romp with someone like Hugh Grant as Bond, but as long as they made a good and entertaining film of it. Similarly, I'll welcome CR as a Bourne-influenced gritfest with Craig as 007, but, again, the main thing is (obviously) that the film is good and entertaining. Goofy? Gritty? Whatever, but just do it well.

(What I don't like is a messy fudge of goofy and gritty elements that just don't go together, like THE WORLD IS NOT ENOUGH.)

#42 Harmsway

Harmsway

    Commander

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 13293 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 06:47 PM

(What I don't like is a messy fudge of goofy and gritty elements that just don't go together, like THE WORLD IS NOT ENOUGH.)

View Post

Agreed.

#43 David Schofield

David Schofield

    Commander

  • Discharged
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 3026 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 07:04 PM

I agree with Schofield's interpretation of the Fleming Bond. He loved two women: Vesper and Tracy. All the rest, while he was certainly attracted to and had a level of caring for them, never qualified under love.

View Post


Thanks, Harmsway. But David, please. :)

#44 TheBritishEnd

TheBritishEnd

    Sub-Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • Pip
  • 261 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 07:10 PM

I think my concern is that Casino Royale may become too cutesy with all these "embryonic" elements.  Just as Die Another Day was filled with references to the 19 previous films, my worry here is that Casino Royale will try to explain away every bit of Bond lore.  Not only is it taking the mystery away from Bond, but, well, it's kinda tacky.


My feelings exactly.

They're trying to sell it as being a fresh, creative direction, when it's really just following another trend. Not to mention, Bond is not the deepest character out there- his appeal is that he's an archetype. If you strip that away, you're either going to be left with something that isn't that interesting, or something that is too far removed from what audiences respond to. And sorry, but Purvis and Wade are not the writers I want to see rewriting the character of James Bond.

I'm just waiting for the revelation that 007 has midicholrians.

#45 triviachamp

triviachamp

    Lt. Commander

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPip
  • 1400 posts
  • Location:Toronto

Posted 26 October 2005 - 07:18 PM

They're trying to sell it as being a fresh, creative direction, when it's really just following another trend.


Bond movies have been doing this since about 1971 so what?

#46 Kara Milovy

Kara Milovy

    Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • PipPip
  • 842 posts
  • Location:New York area

Posted 26 October 2005 - 07:25 PM

It all sounds so very serious, doesn't it? They are making a serious James Bond movie, you see, and that of course means "better." I mean, who wants to see another turkey like Dr. No or Goldfinger or Thunderball or You Only Live Twice or Live And Let Die or The Spy Who Loved Me or Octopussy or GoldenEye or...

I've never understood the "no more villains in volcanoes" edict.

But, hey, if they're trying to make another From Russia With Love more power to them. At least they have their feet planted firmly in Fleming, so hopefully Casino Royale really will be another From Russia With Love and not another Licence To Kill or The World Is Not Enough.

View Post

Most of my favorite Bonds are the more serious ones...FRWL, GE, even TSWLM has that lovely, dark little confrontation between Bond and Anya. I think a good mix is essential, you have to laugh, but all of my least favorite Bonds are silly ones; MR, LALD, AVTAK.

I think the Bond series has made more mistakes with humor than with seriousness (TWINE excepted), and I think this script holds real potential.

#47 triviachamp

triviachamp

    Lt. Commander

  • Veterans
  • PipPipPip
  • 1400 posts
  • Location:Toronto

Posted 26 October 2005 - 07:39 PM

:)

I think the Bond series has made more mistakes with humor than with seriousness (TWINE excepted), and I think this script holds real potential.

View Post


I agree. The problem with "goofy Bond" is that first of all comedy is harder than drama and second of all "fun Bond" is often an excuse for laziness and bad writing.
"Of course the plot doesn't make any sense, the film looks cheap and tacky and the dialogue stinks, that's what so funny!" :)

#48 Bondesque

Bondesque

    Sub-Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • Pip
  • 428 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 08:26 PM

Kara:

I am alluding to the hedonistic Bond in his treatement of girls and sex. Think Thunderball (the nurse at Shrublands) or Goldfinger (Dink) My point is that the Dalton (I would have let my kid sister date Dalton he was so honorable) / Brosnan Bonds have usually been "involved" with those they slept with more then Connery, Laz and Moore who all screwed around because "they could".

#49 spynovelfan

spynovelfan

    Commander CMG

  • Discharged
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 5855 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 08:34 PM

They're trying to sell it as being a fresh, creative direction, when it's really just following another trend. 

View Post


True, but can we really have it both ways?

Typical Bond fanboy in 2004: "God, DIE ANOTHER DAY was such rubbish! Invisible cars? What next? An invisible Bond? Can't they just make a proper spy thriller for once? Reintroduce some grit and realism, please, before it's too late!"

Typical Bond fanboy in 2005: "I mean, how *old* is this getting? Bond shouldn't imitate Bourne - leave him alone! Have the wit and the style and the over-the-topness! Volcanoes and everything. That's what makes Bond so special! Enough with all this talk of grit and realism - it doesn't work!"

If you see what I'm saying. :) Isn't there a little of this going on? Whatever they announce they're planning, we're all going to know better. :)

#50 TheBritishEnd

TheBritishEnd

    Sub-Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • Pip
  • 261 posts

Posted 26 October 2005 - 09:00 PM

If you see what I'm saying. :) Isn't there a little of this going on? Whatever they announce they're planning, we're all going to know better. :)

View Post


Oh, definitely. Hey, none of us would be here if we didn't know better than EON! :)

But there's also a bit of the same hypocrisy going on behind the scenes, which is what I was alluding to. They're the ones that gave us the DAD overkill, and now suddenly they're Fleming purists. It's just one extreme to the other, while still completely bypassing the middle ground that fans have really been asking for.

#51 Qwerty

Qwerty

    Commander RNVR

  • Commanding Officers
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 85605 posts
  • Location:New York / Pennsylvania

Posted 26 October 2005 - 09:41 PM

Read this today in the paper. Good to get a daily dose of Bond during a long, dreary day at college. :)

#52 [dark]

[dark]

    Commander RNVR

  • Commanding Officers
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 6239 posts
  • Location:Sydney, Australia

Posted 26 October 2005 - 10:11 PM

I would just love to see Bond seduce a bond GIRL or any girl for no other reason then that he wants to get laid.

We haven't had that since Connery!

View Post

What, you think Moore's Bond bedded Stacy Sutton for the conversation? :)

#53 freemo

freemo

    Commander RNR

  • Veterans Reserve
  • PipPipPip
  • 2995 posts
  • Location:Here

Posted 27 October 2005 - 01:34 AM

I think my concern is that Casino Royale may become too cutesy with all these "embryonic" elements.

Just as Die Another Day was filled with references to the 19 previous films, my worry here is that Casino Royale will try to explain away every bit of Bond lore (SilverFin's major weakness for me was that it was filled with these kind of winks-and-nods; the horse named Martini, Uncle Max's Aston Martin, etc.).  Not only is it taking the mystery away from Bond, but, well, it's kinda tacky.

View Post


Argeed. It kind of reminds me of the start of Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, where we see Indy get his hat, whip, scar, and fear of snakes all in the one day. Blimey!

#54 Kara Milovy

Kara Milovy

    Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • PipPip
  • 842 posts
  • Location:New York area

Posted 27 October 2005 - 02:48 AM

Kara:

I am alluding to the hedonistic Bond in his treatement of girls and sex.  Think Thunderball (the nurse at Shrublands) or Goldfinger (Dink)  My point is that the Dalton (I would have let my kid sister date Dalton he was so honorable) / Brosnan Bonds have usually been "involved" with those they slept with more then Connery, Laz and Moore who all screwed around because "they could".

View Post

With Dalton, he had one film with a fling and a romance, and one film with a "using the bad guy's girlfriend" and a liaison that may or may not have been romantic.

With Brosnan, I think it's "because I can" all over the place with the doctor, the Danish professor, the psychologist, and really, Christmas Jones as well.

#55 Alessandra

Alessandra

    Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • PipPip
  • 768 posts
  • Location:Milan, Italy

Posted 27 October 2005 - 09:10 AM

[QUOTE][quote name='David Schofield' date='26 October 2005 - 19:27']
[quote name='Kara Milovy' date='26 October 2005 - 14:49'][quote name='David Schofield' date='26 October 2005 - 09:36']
Sorry, Kara, Spy, Alessandra, Bond is a bastard. He uses women. Its not that he doesn't know how to settle down: its that he can't, doesn't want to. He doesn't want domesticity. Offering to marry Vesper and going through with it is a diferent matter. Sure, Spy, the quote is from Moonraker - Bond is feeling sorry for himself he didn't get into Gala's knickers, surely. Must be brave, can't show emotion 'cos I've missed out. Sure, he spends a year with Tiffany. A year. Well done him! Then he moves on. He gets over each woman fairly quickly.

Don't romanticise this man. Bond is a sensualist. Women are both his pleasure and his release. Or shall we really say he is Amis' Byronic hero? I think the error is to sympathise with Bond and make him too nice. Kara, to quote Dalton, "he is a bad lad", and not just slightly.

View Post

[/quote][/QUOTE]

I don't agree at all.
Sorry, but from a woman's point of view I think we have a way of seeing Bond things as far as relationship with women are concerned, which is far more "multi-faceted" than that of a man.

Bond is not a bastard at all with women. He may be with the enemy girls (and even there, there's always some sort of involvement which goes beyond just "sex"). But with the girl he gets with at the end of the movie there's always a connection which isn't simply sleeping with someone.
The "oh james" and champagne that Spy cited perfectly describes it.
now, the fact that most men prefer to see him as a bastard because to them it's cooler and they like to see a man who can have all the women he wants and doesn't care, is another thing.
Brosnan-Bond cares for Natalya (I don't know why I always call her natasha!!), and to the point of revealing to her sides of his character that we've never seen before.
Dalton-Bond cares for Pam Bouvier, and picks her over the bad girl despite the bad girl turning "good".. and in that scene, you can see that he isn't simply doing "oh, I'll taste another one", but that he does look at Lupe in a "sorry for you. I love the other one" way. Plus, there's also the factor of the competition between him and Pam which shows even more how he wants to be with her.
Connery-Bond finishes "from russia with love" on a gondola in venice with Tatiana: how is this supposed in any way NOT to be romantic?? it's extremely romantic, and he IS involved!
If he only were a cold bastard with women, there would be no difference between him and his enemies.
And instead, that's always pointed out when enemy girls get involved with him, that he treats them in a different way from their evil lovers. Even if with the bad girl, he doesn't stay at the end of the movie. Bond has a respect for women, even when he beds them to get information since they're enemies. He never dismisses them with "just go do some shopping", he considers them at his same level. (which automatically rules him out of the bastard category). His enemies don't. See Lupe-Dalton vs Lupe-Sanchez in License to Kill.
And also.. us women, we know perfectly when we're dealing with a bastard. Not wanting a long-term committment (which we are aware of with Bond) doesn't at all mean being a bastard. It just means not being able to afford it because you're a spy, and living the moment you have at the fullest. And in that moment he lives with her, Bond really cares about the woman he's with. (this, as said, doesn't apply to bad girls in general, only to the "good" girls he chooses).
It's a "I can't afford to get a stable relationship with a woman" sort of attitude, not a "I don't love any woman" sort of attitude. Much better like this rather than "oh honey you know I will spend my life with you, and will only see you for the rest of my life" while knowing you can't do it! now THAT is being a cool bastard. Not what Bond does.

Edited by Alessandra, 27 October 2005 - 09:16 AM.


#56 David Schofield

David Schofield

    Commander

  • Discharged
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 3026 posts

Posted 27 October 2005 - 09:24 AM

[quote name='Alessandra' date='27 October 2005 - 09:10']
[QUOTE][quote name='David Schofield' date='26 October 2005 - 19:27']
[quote name='Kara Milovy' date='26 October 2005 - 14:49'][quote name='David Schofield' date='26 October 2005 - 09:36']
Sorry, Kara, Spy, Alessandra, Bond is a bastard. He uses women. Its not that he doesn't know how to settle down: its that he can't, doesn't want to. He doesn't want domesticity. Offering to marry Vesper and going through with it is a diferent matter. Sure, Spy, the quote is from Moonraker - Bond is feeling sorry for himself he didn't get into Gala's knickers, surely. Must be brave, can't show emotion 'cos I've missed out. Sure, he spends a year with Tiffany. A year. Well done him! Then he moves on. He gets over each woman fairly quickly.

Don't romanticise this man. Bond is a sensualist. Women are both his pleasure and his release. Or shall we really say he is Amis' Byronic hero? I think the error is to sympathise with Bond and make him too nice. Kara, to quote Dalton, "he is a bad lad", and not just slightly.

View Post

[/quote][/QUOTE]

I don't agree at all.
Sorry, but from a woman's point of view I think we have a way of seeing Bond things as far as relationship with women are concerned, which is far more "multi-faceted" than that of a man.

Bond is not a bastard at all with women. He may be with the enemy girls (and even there, there's always some sort of involvement which goes beyond just "sex"). But with the girl he gets with at the end of the movie there's always a connection which isn't simply sleeping with someone.
The "oh james" and champagne that Spy cited perfectly describes it.
now, the fact that most men prefer to see him as a bastard because to them it's cooler and they like to see a man who can have all the women he wants and doesn't care, is another thing.
Brosnan-Bond cares for Natalya (I don't know why I always call her natasha!!), and to the point of revealing to her sides of his character that we've never seen before.
Dalton-Bond cares for Pam Bouvier, and picks her over the bad girl despite the bad girl turning "good".. and in that scene, you can see that he isn't simply doing "oh, I'll taste another one", but that he does look at Lupe in a "sorry for you. I love the other one" way. Plus, there's also the factor of the competition between him and Pam which shows even more how he wants to be with her.
Connery-Bond finishes "from russia with love" on a gondola in venice with Tatiana: how is this supposed in any way NOT to be romantic?? it's extremely romantic, and he IS involved!
If he only were a cold bastard with women, there would be no difference between him and his enemies.
And instead, that's always pointed out when enemy girls get involved with him, that he treats them in a different way from their evil lovers. Even if with the bad girl, he doesn't stay at the end of the movie. Bond has a respect for women, even when he beds them to get information since they're enemies. He never dismisses them with "just go do some shopping", he considers them at his same level. (which automatically rules him out of the bastard category). His enemies don't. See Lupe-Dalton vs Lupe-Sanchez in License to Kill.
And also.. us women, we know perfectly when we're dealing with a bastard. Not wanting a long-term committment (which we are aware of with Bond) doesn't at all mean being a bastard. It just means not being able to afford it because you're a spy, and living the moment you have at the fullest. And in that moment he lives with her, Bond really cares about the woman he's with. (this, as said, doesn't apply to bad girls in general, only to the "good" girls he chooses).
It's a "I can't afford to get a stable relationship with a woman" sort of attitude, not a "I don't love any woman" sort of attitude. Much better like this rather than "oh honey you know I will spend my life with you, and will only see you for the rest of my life" while knowing you can't do it! now THAT is being a cool bastard. Not what Bond does.

View Post

[/quote]

I would agree that women do view Bond differently, Alessandra. Coincientally, I was putting the subject of this thread and the points made to my wife last night and she totally disagreed with my opinion, whichb is what is in my posts. In fact, the reply you have posted above could have been posted by her from the argument she put to me last night!

However, it still doesn't change my mind! Bond is a bastard. Sure, he PLAYS the romantic with women, makes the right noises and that sort of thing. Hell, he wouldn't get very far if he went out of his way to deliberately treat women badly. Bond knows how to handle women, effectively what women want. It does not mean he loves them. That is a front. Bond is a bad lad. He's the ultimate swine.

#57 spynovelfan

spynovelfan

    Commander CMG

  • Discharged
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 5855 posts

Posted 27 October 2005 - 09:42 AM

Bond is a bastard. Sure, he PLAYS the romantic with women, makes the right noises and that sort of thing. Hell, he wouldn't get very far if he went out of his way to deliberately treat women badly. Bond knows how to handle women, effectively what women want. It does not mean he loves them. That is a front. Bond is a bad lad. He's the ultimate swine.

View Post


It depends a little on which James Bond we're discussing. All the actors have played this in different ways. As I've already said, I think Dalton portrayed Bond as much more of a romantic hero than the others. Someone put it very well when they said you would gladly allow Dalton's Bond to accompany your daughter - but not Connery's.

In Fleming, I think Bond's character is very erratic. From book to book, but even within books. I don't agree that Amis' Bond was Byronic - oh but that he had been! I think Amis' Bond was a standard cut-out Buchan hero, of the type that had been around since the beginnings of the thriller. Noble and rather dull. I think Fleming's Bond alternated between the Byronic and the Buchanic, if you like. Sometimes he seems like a ruthless bastard. His first reaction with Vesper is that he wants to smash her complacency and dominate her. His first reaction with Domino is to imagine what she looks like having sex. Etc. All this - plus the 70 cigarettes and the cruel mouth - tells us he's Byronic. But then a lot of the time he's really very much the noble hero, protecting the girl. There is a very obvious streak of romanticism running through the books. I think it's too easy to say that Bond is pretending to be a romantic. We have *his* thoughts with Gala Brand, and that passage is quite clear: he's a Buchan hero, and he's not got the girl. He wanted her, but someone else got there first. So he assumes the mask of the Bryonic hero.

So I see it the other way round from you. You think Bond puts on a front of being a romantic, when in fact he's a bastard. I think he puts on a front of being a bastard, when in fact he's a romantic.

#58 David Schofield

David Schofield

    Commander

  • Discharged
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 3026 posts

Posted 27 October 2005 - 10:11 AM

In Fleming, I think Bond's character is very erratic. From book to book, but even within books. I don't agree that Amis' Bond was Byronic - oh but  that he had been! I think Amis' Bond was a standard cut-out Buchan hero, of the type that had been around since the beginnings of the thriller. Noble and rather dull. I think Fleming's Bond alternated between the Byronic and the Buchanic, if you like. Sometimes he seems like a ruthless bastard. His first reaction with Vesper is that he wants to smash her complacency and dominate her. His first reaction with Domino is to imagine what she looks like having sex. Etc. All this - plus the 70 cigarettes and the cruel mouth - tells us he's Byronic. But then a lot of the time he's really very much the noble hero, protecting the girl. There is a very obvious streak of romanticism running through the books. I think it's too easy to say that Bond is pretending to be a romantic. We have *his* thoughts with Gala Brand, and that passage is quite clear: he's a Buchan hero, and he's not got the girl. He wanted her, but someone else got there first. So he assumes the mask of the Bryonic hero.

So I see it the other way round from you. You think Bond puts on a front of being a romantic, when in fact he's a bastard. I think he puts on a front of being a bastard, when in fact he's a romantic.

View Post


A few thoughts, Spy, none of it gospel:

Not too familiar with Buchan, Spy, but would Hannay have the thoughts Bond principly has about Gala: get her to France, a small hotel and shag her? I always thought that these were the immoral suggestions implicit in Fleming that caused him so much flack in the 50s?

Amis reading of Bond as Byronic is to fit neatly with Childe Harold and the loss of Tracy - and of course Amis contradicts himself by saying that Bond is essentially dull - the Medium Grade Civil Servant that loved me. I think the Dalton attachment has been diluted by the fact that he did play many typical Byronic heros - Rochester and Rhett Butler, for example.

I think anyone can hide behind the Byronic mask as you indicate with Gala - but isn't it just that, a mask - damn, I missed out on a shag there? I suppose Bond could have strode of having said, "Well, sod you, you bitch. I never fancied you anyway," but its unlikely. Bond plays the part the women want: he is a very thoughtful lover. He knows how to please women. He is very skilled. He rescues women sure because he knows the likely end result: I wonder if Jill Masterson would have been asked to accompany Bond on the train to New York if she had been pig ugly. Bond would probably have said, "Silly cow for getting involved with Goldfinger, sort yourself out."

Is Bond "the man who is only a silhouette" out of fate or out of choice? Personally, I think for Bond to be the sensualist Fleming created, you have to allow him the independence and confidence to chose for himself, not read him as a tragic figure leading a life of druggery as a government killer just because he happens to be good at it (a role Benson was too happy to tag Bond with - and probably Brosnan too).

#59 Alessandra

Alessandra

    Lieutenant

  • Crew
  • PipPip
  • 768 posts
  • Location:Milan, Italy

Posted 27 October 2005 - 10:25 AM

[quote name='David Schofield' date='27 October 2005 - 10:24']
[quote name='Alessandra' date='27 October 2005 - 09:10']
[QUOTE][quote name='David Schofield' date='26 October 2005 - 19:27']
[quote name='Kara Milovy' date='26 October 2005 - 14:49'][quote name='David Schofield' date='26 October 2005 - 09:36']
Sorry, Kara, Spy, Alessandra, Bond is a bastard. He uses women. Its not that he doesn't know how to settle down: its that he can't, doesn't want to. He doesn't want domesticity. Offering to marry Vesper and going through with it is a diferent matter. Sure, Spy, the quote is from Moonraker - Bond is feeling sorry for himself he didn't get into Gala's knickers, surely. Must be brave, can't show emotion 'cos I've missed out. Sure, he spends a year with Tiffany. A year. Well done him! Then he moves on. He gets over each woman fairly quickly.

Don't romanticise this man. Bond is a sensualist. Women are both his pleasure and his release. Or shall we really say he is Amis' Byronic hero? I think the error is to sympathise with Bond and make him too nice. Kara, to quote Dalton, "he is a bad lad", and not just slightly.

View Post

[/quote][/QUOTE]

I don't agree at all.
Sorry, but from a woman's point of view I think we have a way of seeing Bond things as far as relationship with women are concerned, which is far more "multi-faceted" than that of a man.

Bond is not a bastard at all with women. He may be with the enemy girls (and even there, there's always some sort of involvement which goes beyond just "sex"). But with the girl he gets with at the end of the movie there's always a connection which isn't simply sleeping with someone.
The "oh james" and champagne that Spy cited perfectly describes it.
now, the fact that most men prefer to see him as a bastard because to them it's cooler and they like to see a man who can have all the women he wants and doesn't care, is another thing.
Brosnan-Bond cares for Natalya (I don't know why I always call her natasha!!), and to the point of revealing to her sides of his character that we've never seen before.
Dalton-Bond cares for Pam Bouvier, and picks her over the bad girl despite the bad girl turning "good".. and in that scene, you can see that he isn't simply doing "oh, I'll taste another one", but that he does look at Lupe in a "sorry for you. I love the other one" way. Plus, there's also the factor of the competition between him and Pam which shows even more how he wants to be with her.
Connery-Bond finishes "from russia with love" on a gondola in venice with Tatiana: how is this supposed in any way NOT to be romantic?? it's extremely romantic, and he IS involved!
If he only were a cold bastard with women, there would be no difference between him and his enemies.
And instead, that's always pointed out when enemy girls get involved with him, that he treats them in a different way from their evil lovers. Even if with the bad girl, he doesn't stay at the end of the movie. Bond has a respect for women, even when he beds them to get information since they're enemies. He never dismisses them with "just go do some shopping", he considers them at his same level. (which automatically rules him out of the bastard category). His enemies don't. See Lupe-Dalton vs Lupe-Sanchez in License to Kill.
And also.. us women, we know perfectly when we're dealing with a bastard. Not wanting a long-term committment (which we are aware of with Bond) doesn't at all mean being a bastard. It just means not being able to afford it because you're a spy, and living the moment you have at the fullest. And in that moment he lives with her, Bond really cares about the woman he's with. (this, as said, doesn't apply to bad girls in general, only to the "good" girls he chooses).
It's a "I can't afford to get a stable relationship with a woman" sort of attitude, not a "I don't love any woman" sort of attitude. Much better like this rather than "oh honey you know I will spend my life with you, and will only see you for the rest of my life" while knowing you can't do it! now THAT is being a cool bastard. Not what Bond does.

View Post

[/quote]

I would agree that women do view Bond differently, Alessandra. Coincientally, I was putting the subject of this thread and the points made to my wife last night and she totally disagreed with my opinion, whichb is what is in my posts. In fact, the reply you have posted above could have been posted by her from the argument she put to me last night!

However, it still doesn't change my mind! Bond is a bastard. Sure, he PLAYS the romantic with women, makes the right noises and that sort of thing. Hell, he wouldn't get very far if he went out of his way to deliberately treat women badly. Bond knows how to handle women, effectively what women want. It does not mean he loves them. That is a front. Bond is a bad lad. He's the ultimate swine.

View Post

[/quote]

I remain of your wife's opinion! (now you do have a taste on women) LOL :)
It's the other way round, he's a romantic, but puts on the bastard face!
uh-oh.. noticing that Spy said the exact same thing!
well, I agree!
now go tell your wife you rehiterated the concept... and you'll see! LOL :)

#60 spynovelfan

spynovelfan

    Commander CMG

  • Discharged
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 5855 posts

Posted 27 October 2005 - 10:34 AM

Not too familiar with Buchan, Spy, but would Hannay have the thoughts Bond principly has about Gala: get her to France, a small hotel and shag her? I always thought that these were the immoral suggestions implicit in Fleming that caused him so much flack in the 50s?


He's an updated Buchan character. His tastes and attitude to sex and so on are of the late 50s and early 60s, but his sense of duty and so on are very much in the standard thriller mould.

Amis reading of Bond as Byronic is to fit neatly with Childe Harold and the loss of Tracy - and of course Amis contradicts himself by saying that Bond is essentially dull - the Medium Grade Civil Servant that loved me.


Sorry, David, I misunderstood you. I thought you were saying that James Bond in COLONEL SUN was Byronic (which he isn't). I hadn't twigged you were discussing Amis' DOSSIER. It may well be a contradiction the way Amis puts it, but what I'm saying is that that contradiction is in Fleming's character. He is partly a Byronic swashbuckler, with his own cocktail and his fancy clothes and his love of fast cars. And he's partly a Medium Grade Civil Servant, a Buchanesque hero who gets the job done for Queen and Country.

I think the Dalton attachment has been diluted by the fact that he did play many typical Byronic heros - Rochester and Rhett Butler, for example.


Well, I think that he played the part in a similar way to those characters.

I think anyone can hide behind the Byronic mask as you indicate with Gala - but isn't it just that, a mask - damn, I missed out on a shag there?


I don't think so. There's a line about 'Was he starting to feel something for this woman?' It's not just about sex - he thinks she's beautiful, clever, warm. They've gone through hell together. They've kissed. He respects her enormously. She's a female version of him, in the body of a beautiful woman. Read the passage again - I don't have it here to quote from. It's Bond's own thoughts. And those thoughts are that he should hide his emotion and show the face she expects to see - that of the tough secret agent. He doesn't think 'Bang goes the weekend of fine living and exploring each other's bodies' or whatever. He consciously hides his disappointment.

I suppose Bond could have strode of having said, "Well, sod you, you bitch. I never fancied you anyway," but its unlikely.


The passage isn't what Bond says. It's what he *thinks*. If we take it that his thoughts are lies, we can't make any conclusions about his character at all.

Is Bond "the man who is only a silhouette" out of fate or out of choice? Personally, I think for Bond to be the sensualist Fleming created, you have to allow him the independence and confidence to chose for himself, not read him as a tragic figure leading a life of druggery as a government killer just because he happens to be good at it (a role Benson was too happy to tag Bond with - and probably Brosnan too).

View Post


I don't think I've ever said he was a government killer in this thread or elsewhere, have I? :) I don't read Fleming like that at all.